His ethical framework bore strong affinities with the version of pragmatism. Situation ethics demands that we do the most loving thing. As level religious studies situation ethics revision booklet. Emmanuel mounier, personalism, and the catholic worker movement august 1, 1999 by mark and louise zwick emmanuel mounier 19051950 articulated the ideas of personalism, of human persons whose responsibility it is to take an active role in history, even while the ultimate goal is beyond the temporal and beyond human history. Why did pope pius xii oppose situation ethics in 1952. Stephen baskerville is a leading scholar of political science and the author of the new politics of sex and other books and articles on, among other fields, government policies on families. Some virtue ethicists are reluctant to consider principles and standards in business ethics. There are six fundamental things that underlie fletchers situation ethics.
Emmanuel mounier, personalism, and the catholic worker. Ethical issues include abortion, euthanasia, genetic engineering, war, infertility treatment. Emmanuel mounier 19051950 articulated the ideas of personalism, of human persons whose responsibility it is to take an active role in history, even while the ultimate goal is beyond the temporal and beyond human history. Situation ethics page 2 of 4 permission to murder, steal etc, if they are the most loving thing to do in a given situation. He taught as professor of philosophy at boston university which may be. The new moralityjoseph fletcher 1905 1991 develops what he calls an ethical nonsystem. Situation ethics as a guide in moral decision making youtube. Fletcher developed his theory of situational ethics in his books.
The new morality joseph fletcher 19051991 develops what he calls an ethical nonsystem. Ethical personalism proposes to reflect on the person from at least three levels. The main thinker behind situation ethics, was joseph fletcher 19051991. However, situation ethics would be against the use of excessive force, using nuclear, chemical or biological. Fletcher would say that here is a situation where we ought not to follow the principle do not murder but rather do the most loving thing, which in this. Start studying rs utilitarianism and situation ethics premock revision. The new morality from the worlds largest community of readers. Joseph fletcherin 1966 joseph fletcher, an american theologian, published a book, situation ethics, in which he outlines a new approach to christian ethical. Situational ethics, or situation ethics, is a christian ethical theory that was principally developed in the 1960s by the then episcopal priest joseph fletcher. Situational ethics or situation ethics takes into account the particular context of an act when evaluating it ethically, rather than judging it according to absolute moral standards. He believed that we should follow the rules until we need to break them for reasons of love. Kant and natural law are based on reason reason can uncover the right course of action. Apologetics press situation ethicsextended version.
A new attempt toward the foundation of an ethical personalism. Emmanuel mounier, personalism, and the catholic worker movement. Its american form took root in the late nineteenth century, flowered in the twentieth century, and continues its life in the twentyfirst century. There is no rational answer to the question why should i love. Options for social organization interaction of person and environment the sacrament as an expression of personalism the kairos and its ethics situation eithics. In this extract from an article by william murphy logos. Situation ethics is the method of ethical decision making that states that you must consider noble love agape in decision making, and that a moral decision is correct if it is the most loving thing to do. As level religious studies situation ethics revision booklet 1. Personalism is any philosophy that considers personality the supreme value and the key to the measuring of reality. He was born a protestant and became a priest in the episcopal seminary in the 1960s. Joseph fletchers situation ethics is considered in terms of its four working. Rs religious studies alevel ethics revision section for situation ethics covering fundamental.
He was the author of many books, including morals and medicine and the ethics of genetic control. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Situational ethics is thus a teleological or consequential theory, in that it is primarily concerned with the outcome or consequences of an action. It basically states that sometimes other moral principles can be cast aside in certain situations if love is best served. Prudential personalism is an ethical approach that recognizes that human nature is embodied in each individual in a unique manner and, as such, the role of free will and intelligence in decision. Personalism people should be at the centre of the theory. Fletcher says loving is not liking one of the 6 fundamental principles. Pragmatism in situation ethics is the idea that the action in question must realistically. Preceding there are four working principles in the form of pragmatism, relativism, positivism, and personalism. Love is the only absolute it is intrinsically good 2. Four working principles the heart of this explanation of situation ethics lies in its six propositions but there are a few preliminary matters to be made plain first, in the readers interest, so he can know what presuppositions are at work. On the other hand it could be argued that always following the principle of agape, situation ethics has made itself into a deontological theory. Situation ethics created by joseph fletcher, a 20 th century american professor. Bowne gathered a group of talented disciples who carried on his work in a second generation.
Nov 06, 2015 for situationists, personalism is the key to what is good. Men like emil brunner the divine imperative, reinhold niebuhr moral man and immoral society, harvey cox the secular city, dietrich. Based on personalism which considers personal feelings, opinions and perceptions. Love wants the good for anyone, whoever they are 5. Rs utilitarianism and situation ethics premock revision.
Jul 20, 2010 this discussion will provide valuable insight, because personalism lends itself to the development of a loveforneighbor ethics, given that the concept of the person is primary and foundational. Pg 158159 looking at this book from a fiftyyearslater viewpoint, one is perhaps most surprised to see how christianly fletchers approach originally wasparticularly in light of his later secularist and atheistic approach. Personalists come in all shapes and sizes and can be found in any creed, ethnicity, class, sexual or gender orientation, and in any walk of life. Personalism whereas the legalist thinks people should work to laws, the. Igniting a firestorm of controversy upon its publication in 1966, joseph fletchers situation ethics was hailed by many as a muchneeded reformation of moralityand as an invitation to anarchy by others. Situation ethics, the position that moral decision making is contextual or. Nov 07, 2015 give 3 reasons why situation ethics could be seen as a christian ethic 2.
Situation ethics archives page 2 of 3 philosophical. Book situation ethics the new morality published in 1966. His late book personalism, published in 1908, is a popular summary of his philosophy which introduced the term personalism into american philosophical and theological discourse. Ethical theories include kant, natural law, situation ethics, virtue ethics and utilitarianism. This is for edexcels 8, religion and society topic rights and responsibilities, it talks about the pros and cons of situation ethics in moral decision making, and shows how its strong. In the mid1960s, joseph fletcher published the book, situation ethics, thereby securing for himself the dubious distinction, the father of situation ethics 1966. Personalism, a school of philosophy, usually idealist, which asserts that the real is the personal, i. Thus the expression personalist ethics can be and has been predicated of a wide spectrum of ethical thought, ranging from such disparate forms of existential personalism as those espoused by martin buber, jean paul satre, gabriel marcel and others, through the type of situation ethics championed by joseph fletcher, for whom persons are front. Various conceptualizations have been explored, so personalism exists in many different versions, and this makes it somewhat difficult to define as a philosophical and theological movement. The new morality in which he put this theory forward as a middle way approach. The book is introductory and formatted like a textbook. Integrating personalism into virtuebased business ethics. Furthermore, the principle of personalism is another criterion. Situation ethics are based on a single principle which enables man to enter every situation armed with the experience and precedents of past situations, but willing to lay them aside if the principle of love agape is better served by so doing.
The important of jesus commandment of love in christian. This discussion will provide valuable insight, because personalism lends itself to the development of a loveforneighbor ethics, given that the concept of the person is. The goal of the common good, then, is to outline the potential contributions of personalism in this situation. I think it would be best used as a companion to a text book and as a revision aid. The possibility of christian personalism bayer, richard c. Fletcher argues ethics should be related to individual needs and desires, not imposed as law. A journal of catholic thought and culture, wntr, 2008 by william. Apr 27, 2018 introduction situation ethics is a christian ethic, however, it is a very different type of christian ethic to natural law theory. Situation ethics was most famously championed by joseph fletcher 19051991.
We love other persons through god who is the person of love. A great deal has been written about king in terms of his life, activism, and though. Jun 07, 20 the four presumptions or working principles of situation ethics underline the key distinctions both strengths and weaknesses of joseph fletchers unique ethical approach, which attempts to create a middle road between legalistic and antinomian ethics. Max ferdinand scheler august 22, 1874 may 19, 1928 was a german philosopher known for his work in phenomenology, ethics, and philosophical anthropology. Proposing an ethic of loving concern, fletcher suggests that certain actssuch as lying, premarital sex, adultery, or even murdermight be morally right, depending on the circumstances. His book caused a fire storm amongst the public because it legitimised the general postwar dissatisfaction with authority. Rather, in the scope of a general metaphysics the person manifests his singular value and essential role. Basic details a relativist, consequentialist theory. The first main principle of situation ethics is personalism the first order concern. I need some examples to use in my essay about situation ethics, im really struggling to find one could someone gi. Situation ethics ocr religious studies philosophy and ethics a. It focuses on positivism and personalism it is a form of christian ethic.
The relevance of joseph fletchers situation ethics for animal. Pragmatism, positivism, relativism and personalism are the four working principles which mean to be reasonably sure the act you take will work and provide the most loving consequence, accepting situational ethics as a matter of faith and not reason, each situation must be relative to love and bring about the most loving result and finally the needs of people come first rather than a set of rules. For situationists, personalism is the key to what is good. Give 1 of fletchers examples of situation ethics and explain the point of it 3. Igniting a firestorm of controversy upon its publication in 1966, joseph fletchers situation ethics was hailed by many as a muchneeded reformation of morality and as an invitation to anarchy by others. May 04, 2015 as level religious studies situation ethics revision booklet 1. In the final analysis there is only one revolution worth participating in the personalist revolution. Situation ethics can be described as a theory of love, for it holds that, in a moral dilemma, the course of action that is morally right is the one which is the most lovefilled. Give 3 reasons why situation ethics could be seen as a christian ethic 2. Ethics resources for students and teachers ocr a level rs philosophy and ethics.
Lotze in germany and introduced the term personalism into american science, philosophy and theology with his famous book personalism, boston 1908. The new morality library of theological ethics fletcher, joseph on. Joseph fletchers situation ethics is considered in terms of its four working principles and then evaluated by roman catholic and evangelical christian critici slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Fletcher was alert to the charge that situation ethics might just become an ethical free for all. Situation ethics and war st georges philosophy and ethics. Study 15 terms situation ethics quotes flashcards quizlet. It is based on agape love christian unconditional love, and says that we should always do the most loving thing in any situation. Whereas the legalist thinks people should work to laws, the situational ethicist believes that laws benefit. Here i am primarily interested in examining the loveforneighbor portion of this supreme ethic within the context of personalism. Love and justice are the same, is the third proposition of situation ethics, and it. Situational ethics, or situation ethics, is a teleological and consequential theory of. His book situation ethics is used as a model for the situation ethics platform and nearly all later studies and research refer to fletchers model. Religious studies as situation ethics wjec flashcards. First developed by joseph fletcher in situation ethics 1963.
Situation ethics is the most promising road to a moral community. Situation ethics disagrees, you have to start with a positive choice you need to want to do good. Personalism is an intellectual stance that emphasizes the importance of human persons. Situation ethics is subjective, can be used to justify anything and. Christianity, but dating back to the early christian era. The new morality igniting a firestorm of controversy upon its publication in 1966, fletchers work was hailed by many as a much needed reformation of morality and as an invitation to anarchy by others. Philosophy and religion individualism criticism and interpretation personalism. The four presumptions or working principles of situation ethics underline the key distinctions both strengths and weaknesses of joseph fletchers unique ethical approach, which attempts to create a middle road between legalistic and antinomian ethics. Thus, a personalist ethics must start with and address ethics in terms of individuals. But the father of american personalism is borden parker bowne 18471910, a methodist minister, who studied under r. Formalism in ethics and nonformal ethics of values.
Of course, fletcher was by no means the first to advance the ideals of situationism. Personal interests come first, before the natural or scriptural or theoretical or general or logical or anything else 34. Personalist definition of personalist by the free dictionary. What are the four presumptions of situation ethics hubpages. What is meant by the term situation ethics and is love too general a term on which to make moral decisions.
Agape positivism situation ethics is based on a positivist stance the free decision to do the most loving thing. This may mean going to war augustine said that while we may go to war, we should love our enemies as jesus instructed even as we kill them. A summary of the moral decision making theory of situation ethics. Articulating from various philosophical and religious angles and traditions the ontological and inalienable value of the human person, i. Situation ethics is an ethical theory that was principally developed in the 1960s by the episcopal priest joseph fletcher. The personalism, theology, and ethics of martin luther king, jr. Formalism in ethics and nonformal ethics of values book. In the mid1960s, joseph fletcher published the book, situation ethics, thereby securing for himself the dubious distinction the father of situation ethics 1966. With this scheler in no way holds the position of situation ethics, because he in no way thinks that the moral life.
1609 293 1430 1648 1209 1133 1605 143 164 1532 1345 482 103 335 1244 1264 1387 1271 1506 1528 844 785 65 1439 1055 1336 282 344 1069 467 1282 1275 1008 1191 1651 996 1026 517 671 339 502 1087 624 1433 768 1392