He said he needed a doctors letter so the police or an ambulance. Court case threatens physicianpatient confidentiality. Physician breach of patient confidentiality among individuals. Paucity of cases one prefatory note to this paper must be the dearth of cases reported for breach of confidentiality in psychotherapy. Respect for confidentiality is important to safeguard the wellbeing of patients and ensure the confidence of society in the doctorpatient relationship. Doctors use of smartphones could threaten patient confidentiality. Pdf the law views confidentiality as a balance of public interests rather than a right afforded to the individual, and this potentially conflicts. To determine whether the sex, race, or sexual preference of a patient infected with immunodeficiency virus hiv influences a physician s decision to breach patient confidentiality, tennessee primary care physicians were mailed a questionnaire containing a case study in which an hivinfected patient presented a risk to a third party.
Doctor tricked into giving confidential info on patient with mental. Confidentiality covers all medical records including xrays, labreports, etc. Follow this link for a thorough explanation of how a breach of doctorpatient confidentiality could be considered medical malpractice. By means of direct observation, our study examines real situations in which there has. Sep 02, 2016 these last cases, in which personnel breached the patients confidentiality in an intentional mannerby accessing electronic records to consult the clinical data of acquaintances who were not their patients and without the patients consent. A healthcare worker at a washington state medical center was fired in 2017 for improperly accessing over 600 confidential patient health records. It has undermined her trust in doctors and the entire medical. Medical records breach at tampa general, usf exposes womans. When a patient finds out that such a disclosure has been made, the patient may reflexively claim that an unlawful breach of confidentiality occurred. Breach of confidentiality is a common law tort, which means it can be brought as a civil lawsuit against the individual who breached the agreement.
Doctors may be uncomfortable knowing about the extramarital activities of their patients, but confidentiality is a key part of the doctor patient relationship. Smc, which convened a disciplinary tribunal to hear the case. Protecting a patients confidentiality does matter you might think few reported cases deal with the important duty of protecting a patients privacy and confidentiality. Doctorpatient confidentiality is essential to successful treatment and diagnosis of a patients condition. Patients have a right to expect that their private medical information will be kept confidential. Breaches of doctorpatient confidentiality healthcare. Jessica wilen berg is professor of law and bioethics, case western reserve. Ocrs website makes public a list of these cases, highlighting them on. A confidential relationship between physician and patient is essential for the free flow of information necessary for sound medical care. He is concerned about the possibility of having hiv, and requests testing. With technological advances, patient confidentiality has entered unchartered territory and may cover a number of actions beyond the disclosure of information.
Doctors may be uncomfortable knowing about the extramarital activities of their patients, but confidentiality is a key part of the doctorpatient relationship. By now, in the evolution of the health insurance portability and accountability act hipaa patient privacy guarantees, doctors dont need to be. Patient sues clinician for privacy violation after. For instance, a recent lawsuit filed by a patient in california highlights the privacy and data risks inherent in. Patients sue hospital after breach may 05, 2011, 5. Breaching confidentiality medical protection society. Jun 28, 2010 in another breach of patient privacy by the same hospital, patient records were faxed to the wrong doctor, because the name of the patient s er doctor was not correctly entered into the system. A real case involving the breach of confidentiality of patient with a std diagnosis, involved a nurse from guthrie clinic steuben in corning, new york. Most often, a breach can happen when a nurse shares patient information with a person who is not a member of the healthcare team or when a patient s electronic medical record is accessed for a personal reason. Breach of this doctorpatient confidentiality is considered a form of medical malpractice under federal law. A breach of confidentiality occurs when a patients private information is disclosed to a third party without their consent. Rn breaches patient confidentiality policy to check work. Upholding patient confidentiality policy and privacy is a fundamental obligation for every nurse. The suit alleges breach of the doctorpatient confidentiality owed to mr.
A 35 year old male comes to you and confesses he is currently abusing iv drugs. New yorks public policy would be furthered by permitting a cause of action for breach of medical confidentiality, even in cases where an employee has acted outside the scope of employment, because patients must reveal medical data in order to obtain care from the medical corporation and the patient has no way of protecting against its. When patientphysician confidentiality conflicts with the. Over the years, many articles have been written by legal commentators on malpractice in the area of psychiatry. When known, we explain how the breach occurred, the consequences to patients that may have had their phi compromised, and the. Confidentiality agreements can be complicated, and they are legally binding. Protecting a patients confidentiality does matter nurse. Smiths statement was in fact an apology under the definition spelled out in law. Respect for confidentiality is important to safeguard the wellbeing of patients and ensure the confidence of society in the doctor patient relationship. One lpn found out the hard way that such cases exist, and she became the only defendant in the case. Jun 28, 2010 in another breach of patient privacy by the same hospital, patient records were faxed to the wrong doctor, because the name of the patients er doctor was not correctly entered into the system. February 24, 2015 a former patient filed a lawsuit against aventura hospital and medical center following the facilitys third healthcare data breach in two years.
The psychiatrist gave confidential information about a patients. University records show mcnew worked at usf from november 2009 to august 2012. Doctorpatient confidentiality gets spotlight in aurora. In another breach of patient privacy by the same hospital, patient records were faxed to the wrong doctor, because the name of the patients er doctor was not correctly entered into the system. But the states high court was unconvinced, and in last months ruling it made clear why. Patient confidentiality time, types, definition, purpose. In the 20th century, the law of breach of confidence has expanded due to the case of attorneygeneral v guardian newspaper, where lord keith dictates that. Patient confidentiality is protected under state law.
Patients sue hospital after breach health data management. In such cases a doctor cannot decline to answer questions in court on the grounds of doctorpatient confidentiality. These last cases, in which personnel breached the patients confidentiality in an intentional mannerby accessing electronic records to consult the clinical data of acquaintances who were not their patients and without the patients consent. Eggeson contacted the hospital and, without filing suit, secured a confidential settlement for frances. The hospital is checking its database for accuracy. Famous and notorious cases, publication and privacy.
The professional duty of confidentiality covers not only what a patient may reveal to the doctor, but also what a doctor may independently conclude or form an opinion about, based on his or her examination or assessment of the patient. Confidentiality is a fundamental basis of the doctorpatient relationship as patients have a right to. The practice hired an attorney who filed a motion to dismiss the case, based on the contention. Thus in duchess of argyll v duke of argyll 1967 ch 302 an injunction was granted against the revelation of. Oct 16, 2015 confidentiality agreements can be complicated, and they are legally binding. The case raises an important issue about when a doctor should breach a patients confidentiality. Notice that a breach of confidentiality is not justified simply because you think it would be better for the patient if others knew about a certain condition or problem. After receiving a positive result he states he cannot and will not tell his wife of his status. Again, it is a matter of weighing the pros and cons between keeping and breaching confidentiality. To determine whether the sex, race, or sexual preference of a patient infected with immunodeficiency virus hiv influences a physicians decision to breach patient confidentiality, tennessee primary care physicians were mailed a questionnaire containing a case study in which an hivinfected patient presented a risk to a third party. The american medical association believes that an individual seeking treatment or help from a medical professional should be able to do so without fear of disclosure of personal information to other medical professionals or laypeople. The physicians duty to keep patient information confidential dates back at least to the. Court case threatens physicianpatient confidentiality american.
Unless youre a physician who uses their phone to contact patients, in which case that contact list might be a sneaky but real hipaa violation. In this interaction, a physician was ultimately responsible for a confidentiality breach an ethically and legally inappropriate action. Patients can reasonably expect that communications with a physician be confidential as long as those communications occur during medical treatment. Breach in the physician s duty to protect patient confidentiality. This duty of confidentiality is subject to certain exceptions that are ethically justified because of overriding social. Breach of confidence involves no more than an invasion of personal privacy. Jun 01, 2008 in such cases a doctor cannot decline to answer questions in court on the grounds of doctor patient confidentiality. Lancet felt that confidentiality owed to the living is doubly owed to the dead, and the british medical association strongly asserted its view that the death ofthe patient did not terminate the obligation to secrecy.
Dec 23, 2019 breach of this doctor patient confidentiality is considered a form of medical malpractice under federal law. A real case involving the breach of confidentiality of. Physicians in turn have an ethical obligation to preserve the confidentiality of information gathered in association with the care of the patient. As of 2003, patient confidentiality was protected by federal statute.
Patient physician confidentiality is a fundamental tenet of medical ethics. Confidentiality is the right of an individual to have personal, identifiable medical information kept private. But the court did not allow the family to pursue its claim of intentional infliction of emotional distress against. The liability of psychotherapists for breach of confidentiality. Nov 30, 2018 a breach of confidentiality occurs when a patient s private information is disclosed to a third party without their consent. This nurse learned the diagnosis of this patient, who was the boyfriend of her sisterinlaw, and texted her sisterinlaw six times regarding the patients diagnosis. The patients privacy, respect for patient confidentiality and the importance of protecting the privacy of patients was emphasised in the context of medical ethics. They should feel free to fully disclose sensitive personal information to enable their physician to most effectively provide needed services.
Our hipaa breach news section covers hipaa breaches such as unauthorized disclosures of protected health information phi, improper disposal of phi, unauthorized phi access by cybercriminals and rogue healthcare employees, and other security and privacy breaches. For instance, a recent lawsuit filed by a patient in california highlights the privacy and data risks inherent in this age of smartphones and social media. What if patients no longer felt safe sharing personalyet crucialinformation with their physicians. The medical center discovered the breach during a routine audit. The second set of allegations was not at all typical. Such information should be available only to the physician of record and other health care and insurance personnel as necessary. The employee viewed information like addresses, phone numbers, diagnoses, and the social security numbers of patients. Principle iv of the american medical associations code of medical ethicsstates, a physician shall safeguard patient confidences and privacy within the constraints of the law 1. The success of a classaction lawsuit versus kaiser, after a breach affected 49,000 patients, remains in question following a look at recent breach suit decisions.
A case to be heard by the washington supreme court threatens the integrity of the patientphysician relationship, potentially raising new obstacles to communication and trust. The aim of our study is to examine real situations in which there has been a breach of confidentiality, by means of direct observation in clinical practice. Smallscale violations of medical privacy often cause. In most cases, patient should be notified that confidentiality is to be violated. Doctorpatient confidentiality gets spotlight in aurora theater shooting case. Patients are at risk of having their confidentiality breached because up to. A patient sued a gynecology practice after it mailed her records to a court following a subpoena. The first breach occurred early july 15 when four desktop computers containing records of nearly 4 million patients were stolen from an amg administrative office in park ridge, illinois. In such cases, the disclosure is typically made to a persons reasonably able to prevent or lessen the threat, including the target of the threat. There are limited exceptions to this, including disclosures to state health officials and court orders requiring medical records to be produced. If a patient does not trust her physician, she may not seek help when she needs it or may not divulge signi cant information that would support her diagnosis 9 the consequences of breach patient. It is a good idea to consult an experienced attorney during the process. Previously, when faced with a vexing case, one would refer the patient to a.
Impaction of breaching patient confidentiality the united states encourage healthcare organizations to convert from paper charting to ehr. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Huge data breach at health system leads to biggest ever. Oct 14, 2015 what if patients no longer felt safe sharing personalyet crucialinformation with their physicians. Patient privacy and confidentiality in the ambulance services. Only in a setting of trust can a patient share the private.
Breach in the physicians duty to protect patient confidentiality. In line with sections of the nsw evidence act 1995 regarding protected communications, if there was any question as to whether certain confidential information should be divulged in evidence, it would be a matter for the judge to. Doctor patient confidentiality gets spotlight in aurora theater shooting case. Paragraph 22 of the gmc guidance serious communicable diseases see above allows disclosure to a known sexual contact where the patient has not informed that person and. Tampa general and usf officials acknowledged the breach, but declined to discuss details, citing patient privacy laws. It sure is magic to have all those numbers connected to names and stored electronically on our mobile devices. Any list enumerating the uses of mobile phones among doctors would be incomplete. Breaches that expose the health details of just a patient or two are. In this case, the surgeon and anyone else in the clinical team who was aware of the nature of the objects within mr ys body should have reported the presence of suspected illegal drugs in mr ys possession. The issue of protecting patient confidentiality and phi has renewed importance with the longawaited publication of the final privacy rules on january 17. It is necessary to balance the potential harms of non disclosure with the harms that might result from disclosure without consent in breach of the duty of confidentiality.
1171 14 676 476 1341 600 357 1447 1250 650 391 1400 789 1033 326 49 1130 1052 40 768 995 942 1300 1595 763 969 1400 67 97 833 462 244 169 1364 752 1408 232